Sea Island Coffee – Costa Rica Geisha


December 2, 2012 by Beans Ahoy

Now you probably could not ask a more biased person to offer his opinion on Geisha coffee. I believe Geisha to be of the finest variety of coffees available. It is not for everyone though. Geisha has an unusual aroma and flavour. It is perhaps the most difficult aroma and taste to try and describe to someone. There are hints of various wild flowers, honey, citrus fruits, and tartness, but at the end of the day there is a flavour that you just don’t get anywhere else.

Geisha originated in Ethiopia, but frankly, it has grown far better in South and Central America. The main countries that have taken to growing the Geisha variety of bean is Panama, Costa Rica, and Columbia. I have a review posted on the 2007 Panamanian Geisha in the November 2012 archive, and it is perhaps the first, and last time I have given a 10.0. This particular coffee had, what was in my opinion, the perfect growing season and at the end of the day you have to stake your claim and say what you believe to be the best coffee in the world. The Panamanian Geisha of that season was it.

Big shoes then for the CR Geisha to fill. I should say that my first impression of the coffee was a bit of a shock. The beans were remarkably wholesome looking. Geisha has a tendency to develop a weedy, almost emaciated bean as yields are very low. I have also tasted Geisha from Costa Rica before and it was a bit of a disappointment. There just isn’t the aroma, taste, or complexity to the coffee. It was flat, unappealing, and a let down. Part of the problem I believe is down to the higher levels of light exposure on the Costa Rican Geisha. This increases yields and allows for easier processing but destroys the very delicate tastes of Geisha.

But, and it’s a big but, of the three coffees I tasted from Sea Island Coffee this was the most impressive. They have managed to capture that Geisha taste, and have roasted perfectly to capture all the delicate flavours of the bean. Is it at the level of the Panamanian Geishas? No, but it is very close. There is a slight lack of lingering after taste which can be very powerful in heavier shade Geishas. There is also a slightly two dimensional taste. Certainly, the ingredients of a good geisha coffee are there, but they aren’t absolutely perfectly sewn together, but really this is not very important because this is still an exceptional coffee that you would be privileged to drink every day. The faults in it are mainly academic, and don’t detract from the fact that you are going to have a fantastic cup. It compares well to some of the fantastic Geishas that Colombia has been producing. This will be a coffee to watch in the future.

Tasting Note:

Typically Geisha. Strong tones of honeysuckle, and lavender, with that element of “Geisha-ness”, that full mouth taste and aroma. After taste is a little short, and the flavours don’t quite develop in the mouth as much as some other Geishas. The taste profile remains static through the mouthful. These elements don’t really change as the cup cools, but they do intensify. A great cup and well worth it. Deficiencies will not change your enjoyment of this coffee. 9.2/10.0


3 thoughts on “Sea Island Coffee – Costa Rica Geisha

  1. LoveHoundUK says:

    Have you tried a Geisha from Malawi. When I had my coffee shop our roaster in Barcelona had a fantastic Malawi Mzuzu Geisha.
    It was a hit in our coffee everyone liked the aroma the taste and I loved it.
    I havent found any more since closing the shop. I think I need to look some out.
    Again I love your post and blog.

  2. Beans Ahoy says:

    Thanks! I have had Malawi Geisha, but it was quite some time ago now, and it wan’t a proper cupping. I recently had a Bourbon from Malawi that was a lot better than has been coming out of there in recent years. There is a company called Kopi I found that does it, but couldn’t comment on quality.

  3. The Coffee Bear says:

    It is actually GESHA not Geisha. That having been said I agree Gesha is, if roasted correctly, the best coffee by a long way. VERY worried to see Starbucks is offering it now at $7.00 a cup, this could destroy the coffee altogether.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: